Derek Winnert

The American Friend [Der Amerikanische Freund] **** (1977, Dennis Hopper, Bruno Ganz, Lisa Kreuzer, Gérard Blain) – Classic Movie Review 132

600full-the-american-friend-screenshot

‘There’s no such thing as a perfect murder. That’s just a parlour game, trying to dream one up. Of course you could say there are a lot of unsolved murders. That’s different.’

Patricia Highsmith’s brilliant, nail-biting 1974 bestselling thriller Ripley’s Game (the third book in her Tom Ripley sequence) becomes an impressively slick and dark-toned movie, Der Amerikanische Freund (1977),  under German writer-director Wim Wenders, maker of Wings of Desire and Paris, Texas.

1

Dennis Hopper stars as the talented Mr Tom Ripley, a refined art forging dealer and serial killer who detests murder. He prefers someone else to do his dirty work, if possible.

He’s asked by his lowlife criminal underworld buddy Raoul Minot (Reeves in the book) to help him out with a couple of convenient killings. He feels too fastidious to do it himself and thinks of saying no. And then, just by accident, he finds the right man for the job, or thinks he does.

friend9

Bruno Ganz co-stars as a Swiss picture framer living in Hamburg called Jonathan Zimmerman (he’s an Englishman called Trevanny living in Fontainebleau in the book), exactly the man with no criminal record Ripley needs, who would perhaps be prepared to commit ‘two simple murders’ for a generous fee.

Plus, Ripley, offended by an offhand remark at an art auction, doesn’t like the man, at first, and wants to ensnare him in his trap for a little sadistic sport. It’s a game. At the start of the story, we watch a psychopathic anti-hero in the ultra-creepy process of the seduction of an ordinary decent man.

2

Zimmermann is not the criminal type, let alone the killer sort. But, convinced by faked lab reports that he’s dying of his rare incurable leukaemia-type blood disease, he steps up to face the moral dilemma Ripley imposes on him and reluctantly involves himself in Ripley’s Game.

In return for a lot of money to leave to his wife and kid for after he’s gone, Zimmermann starts the business of committing the murder of two lowlife victims he doesn’t know and Ripley needs out of the way. It turns out he’s going to need a bit of help from Ripley…

3

Wenders is probably the wrong director for this adaptation, and he doesn’t make the most of all the chances the story offers. He seems to be more interested in making a European art movie rather than a neo-noir thriller. He doesn’t seem really to get Highsmith properly, or wants to change her work so much to make it his own that he’s not interested in being faithful to the spirit of the material.

It’s good that he concentrates on developing the oddball character studies and the fascinating relationship between the two men. But he’s not so good at the nuts and bolts of the apparatus of the thriller and mechanics of its wonderful plot.

american-friend2

Perhaps what’s partly wrong is down to the continual daily re-writing and Hopper’s constant improvising of his dialogue, taking things further and further away from Highsmith and more and more into chaos. It’s surprising, then, that the finished film’s so smooth, polished and unmuddled.

And the movie rivets the attention anyway thanks to the total indestructibility and power of Highsmith’s characters and story. Wenders manages a lot of atmosphere and tension throughout and there are some memorable sequences, especially the multi-murder scene of mayhem on the train, which is also a highlight of Highsmith’s book and the 2002 remake Ripley’s Game. Robby Müller’s moody, noirish colour cinematography is a brilliant adornment to the movie.

4

Hopper is not ideally cast as Ripley, the amoral murdering ‘friend’ of the title (with ‘friends’ like this who needs enemies?). And Ganz is not really quite right as the bewildered framer, either. But nothing stops their barnstorming performances, quirky, involving and ultimately memorable. Both performances are incredibly intense, Hopper’s outwardly so and Ganz’s inwardly.

Lisa Kreuzer does well in the less rewarding role of Zimmermann’s wife Marianne, and also effective are Nicholas Ray as the artist Derwatt who’s faked his own death, Gérard Blain as Ripley’s lowlife buddy Raoul Minot and Samuel Fuller as an American mobster.

500full

Whatever you think about it, it’s clearly a must-see for all thriller fans, completing your Ripley collection. And it’s fascinating to compare with the utterly different 2003 remake Ripley’s Game or with the film-making styles of Plein Soleil or The Talented Mr Ripley, the two versions of the first Ripley book.

5

The final delicious irony of the German title of Ripley’s Game is that Ripley learns to respect Zimmermann and does actually become his American Friend before the movie’s over. But, by then,  it’s all too late. There are so many weird corners in this story that it repays endless revisits, in either film or book form.

http://derekwinnert.com/the-talented-mr-ripley-classic-film-review-41/

http://derekwinnert.com/ripleys-game-classic-film-review-108/

© Derek Winnert Classic Movie Review 132

Check out more film reviews on derekwinnert.com

1

1

1

1

7

Comments are closed.

Recent articles

Recent comments

Skip to toolbar